The research team led by cloning pioneer Prof. Hwang Woo-suk did use
egg cells donated by junior researchers for a stem cell project in
2003, it was revealed Tuesday. The confirmation adds more fuel to
debate surrounding the ethics of occyte procurement for Hwang��s
groundbreaking studies after a collaborator on Monday admitted he paid
women to donate eggs. Speaking on condition of anonymity, a source close to Hwang��s team
said allegations that two female researchers in the team donated egg
cells for the experiments in 2003 were true.Critics say using ova
donated by junior researchers would be unethical because it could
involve coercion. Lee Byeong-chun, a professor of veterinary medicine at Seoul
National University who also participated in Hwang��s research, said a
committee at SNU College of Veterinary Medicine was investigating all
researchers who worked in Hwang��s lab. No results are available because
the college��s Institutional Review Board has not finished its
investigation of researchers currently living abroad, Lee added. That suggests that at least one of the junior researchers who
donated eggs is living abroad. The researcher was reportedly a graduate
student who invented a new way of removing the nucleus from eggs and is
now working at a research institute in a U.S. university. Meanwhile, the government plans to revise regulations on occyte donations.
The Ministry of Health and Welfare said there was a need to draw
a clear line between voluntary donation and donation for gain. It is
considering permitting egg donations to family and relatives, or to a
specifically designated recipient. A committee on embryonic cell
research under the National Bioethics Committee is reportedly pushing
for guidelines that would legalize a certain amount of compensation for
egg donors. Kim Young-sik of the Ministry of Science and Technology said
the ministry��s position was that all of Hwang��s research so far has
been within the bounds of domestic law, adding the team would get its
financial support according to plan. ([email protected] )
|